Why Plastic Injection Molded Parts Fail After the CAD Looks “Done”

A finished CAD file is an important step in developing a plastic injection molded part, but it doesn’t necessarily mean that the part is ready for production.

A part can look perfect on a computer screen, meet the intended dimensions, and appear to have all the necessary features. That is, until problems emerge once that design moves into tooling, production, or its intended application.

Simply put, designing a part that looks right isn’t the same as designing a part for manufacturability and reliable performance. There are a variety of details that influence whether a plastic part will work as intended, and they can be easy to overlook without extensive experience with plastic part design or the injection molding process in general.

Understanding where these failures originate can help OEMs, engineers, and procurement teams turn seemingly complete CAD files into designs that truly address manufacturability and long-term production success. In this article, we’ll identify potential part design problems to address before investing in tooling or committing to production.

6 Factors That Can Cause Plastic Injection Molded Parts to Fail

The issue with a lot of CAD files isn’t that the drawing itself is bad; it’s that the design is missing a key element or consideration. Let’s break down seven common factors that can be overlooked when designing plastic injection molded parts.

1. Functional Considerations: When the Part Doesn’t Perform as Intended

A plastic part can be manufactured exactly according to its CAD file and still fail to perform its intended function.

Let’s consider two plastic components that need to slide against one another. The CAD file may show the correct dimensions and clearances, but the material selected has a high coefficient of friction. The resulting parts may fit together perfectly, but they don’t appropriately slide together, despite the CAD file seeming correct.

How to address functional issues:

Make functionality a part of the initial design process rather than a decision made after the geometry is complete. Before finalizing the CAD file, have an engineer evaluate the part’s intended application and the properties required for it to function properly. This process includes understanding how it interacts with other components, whether it needs to move, and what material characteristics are necessary to perform those functions.

2. Mechanical Considerations: When the Part Can’t Withstand Physical Demands

Mechanical failures occur when a plastic part isn’t designed to withstand the forces or environmental conditions it encounters during use. A CAD file may appear structurally sound, but can still falter when exposed to stress, temperature, or repeated loading.

Christopher Miedza, President and CEO of PharoPLAST, points to polycarbonate as an example of why plastics-specific design experience matters. Polycarbonate can be notch-sensitive, meaning that sharp corners or other geometric features can create areas of concentrated stress.

“Material not matching the design is a very common problem,” Christopher explained. “If a designer doesn’t incorporate the necessary rounds or radii in the CAD file, it can lead to stress cracking and other catastrophic failures because of incorrect part design and material selection.”

How to address mechanical issues:

An engineer with deep plastics experience should evaluate your part for key details like expected mechanical loads, temperature exposure, and material properties before releasing a design for tooling. This review can help eliminate mechanical failures by making specific changes based on your application, including:

  • Adjusting wall thicknesses
  • Incorporating appropriate radii
  • Modifying the geometry
  • Selecting a material better suited to the operating conditions

3. Aesthetic Considerations: When the Finished Part Doesn’t Meet Appearance Requirements

A part can function correctly and still fail because it simply doesn’t look right.

Aesthetic failures are particularly important for transparent plastic components or products with specific visual standards. For example, excessive wall thickness combined with an unsuitable material can create visible bubbles or voids within a transparent molded part.

How to address aesthetic issues:

Appearance requirements should be established and evaluated alongside the part’s functional and mechanical requirements.

For transparent or appearance-critical components, engineers need to evaluate how the selected material interacts with wall thickness, geometry, and the molding process. When transferring an existing mold, it’s also important to understand why the original material was selected before substituting another resin.

4. Chemical Incompatibility: When the Material Can’t Withstand Its Environment

Chemical compatibility is another factor that may not be obvious when reviewing a completed CAD file, but will cause parts to deteriorate once they’re used in their operating environment.

The chemicals in question don’t necessarily need to be part of the component’s primary function. According to Christopher, even alcohol and other cleaning agents can cause cracks and other problems that shorten part life.

How to address chemical incompatibility:

Always consider a part’s environment when finalizing material selection and part design. Identify any chemicals, cleaning agents, and other substances that the part may contact throughout its service life. Reviewing chemical compatibility early can help determine whether the original material is appropriate or whether another resin should be considered before tooling begins.

5. Improper Calculations: When the Design Doesn’t Account for Real-World Forces

A CAD model can accurately represent a component’s geometry, but the finished component may fail even though it was manufactured according to the drawing. A part design needs to account for the physical demands of the application in addition to the component’s shape and dimensions.

“A lack of vision into how a part will be used often leads to parts that are not designed for impact,” Christopher explained. “We once designed a plastic component used to transport vacuum tubes. Even if that part had a good CAD file, those tubes would shatter if we selected the wrong material for that application.”

How to address improper calculations:

Design teams should evaluate the forces a component may experience throughout its intended use, including impact, mechanical loading, and other application-specific demands. Those requirements should inform both the part geometry and material selection that go into developing a proper CAD file.

6. Fundamental Design Issues: When the Part is Not Optimized for Injection Molding

A design may be technically sound but still difficult or impractical to manufacture through injection molding. This issue often happens when the original design doesn’t account for how the mold will operate or how molten plastic will flow through it.

For example, a part that may be relatively straightforward to 3D print may introduce unnecessary tooling complexities that pose serious manufacturability issues.

“You can build a tool where the part looks moldable, but there’s just no way it’s possible to physically mold it,” Christopher shared. “There are so many variables when you design a part, and it’s critical that the CAD file is designed around the riles of how molding works”

How to address designs that aren’t optimized for molding:

Before finalizing a CAD file, engineers should conduct a Design for Manufacturability (DFM) review to evaluate whether the part can be produced efficiently using the intended material and injection molding process. This process can identify and address issues like:

  • Uneven wall thicknesses: Significant variations can contribute to inconsistent cooling, sink marks, and other molding defects.
  • Unsupported bosses: Features that lack adequate support may create structural or manufacturing problems.
  • Insufficient draft: Features without appropriate draft angles can make it difficult to release the finished part from the mold.
  • Complex internal features: Undercuts or other geometric details may require additional tooling mechanisms that complicate production.
  • Material flow limitations: Thin sections or long flow distances may make it difficult for molten plastic to fill the mold completely.
  • Hollow parts: Producing a hollow part requires specialized tooling or processes, and certain hollow designs may not be moldable at all.

It’s also essential that anyone conducting a DFM review has extensive experience with plastic injection molding. A deep understanding of different resins and the molding process provide a level of expertise needed to prevent inevitable failures and simplify manufacturing.

Catch CAD File Issues Before They Create Production Problems

A completed CAD file is only one part of preparing a plastic component for production. The best plastic parts require a balance of both mechanical engineering and industrial design to mold better products designed for manufacturability without adding extra costs.

At PharoPLAST, we take an engineering-led approach to custom plastic injection molding because we understand how closely part design, plastic material selection, tooling, and production are connected. We provide full design support for plastic injection molded parts, working directly with customers to support manufacturability, speed to market, and long-term success.

Whether you have an existing CAD model that needs review or need a fully designed part, PharoPLAST is here to ensure your designs are right before they head to production. Talk to a PharoPLAST engineer about how we can deliver parts that mold cleanly, launch on time, and stay in production without constant adjustments.

Recent Posts

(DO NOT DELETE BELOW SECTION)

Reference/Dev Links: